Dueling Reviews #4

Joey's pre-watch thoughts:

I'm hoping for early Smallville.

Joey's Summary:

I really enjoyed it. Even though they laid on the "Kara will be her own woman" stuff pretty thick.

Joey's Rating: 7.5

Joey's Season Prediction: 2

Aaron's pre-watch thoughts:

Looks great I will watch it for as long as it is on I think.

Aaron's summary:

The story of Kal-El's cousin Kara Zor-El. I really liked this pilot. I am afraid that it will either be cancelled early or live on but twisted by caving to public opinion.

Aaron's Rating: 8.27

Aaron's Season Prediction: Will finish the first but not be picked up for a second.

Joey's pre-watch thoughts:

Every channel wants a Game of Thrones.

Joey's Summary:

I'm having a hard time summing this one up. It wasn't terrible; it wasn't great. It had moments of story-telling. It had moments of senseless gore. It had moments where the authors clearly phoned it in.

Joey's Rating: 6

Joey's Season Prediction: 3

Aaron's pre-watch thoughts:

I have heard it is similar to Vikings which I just couldn't get into.

Aaron's summary:

A rebel replaces an executioner because a witch tells him to. A little rough around the edges, but it is a pilot. I am willing to see if they can tighten it up.

Aaron's Rating: 4.95

Aaron's Season Prediction:

However long Vikings goes. I guess 3-4 seasons.